Pros and cons of adaptive user interfaces (AUIs)
Is this versatile user interface right for your application?There are many different types of user interfaces that allow human operators to control machines and devices. These include Human Machine Interfaces (HMIs), tangible user interfaces, direct voice interfaces, natural user interfaces, and kinetic user interfaces, among others. One lesser-known type of user interface is the Adaptive User Interface, or AUI. As its name suggests, an AUI is designed to “adapt” to the needs of the user, offering them a personalized experience.
AUIs are able to adapt their layouts and design elements based on the user, as opposed to most other types of user interfaces that are static. AUIs use logically distinct components, such as interactive documents and applications, to automatically change and create a specific optical experience for the user. Rather than relying on traditional interface design, an AUI’s design is based on the device’s features and the knowledge of when and how users will access it.
AUI design is responsive, meaning it can adjust to different screen sizes and resolutions. This ensures a consistent and optimal user experience across various devices, from desktop computers to tablets and smartphones. Because of their smart and flexible design, AUIs can incorporate real-time data and updates, as well as learn from user interactions over time and adapt accordingly.
Adaptive user interface pros
What benefits do AUIs provide? The primary advantage of AUIs is their adaptability. While most interfaces provide the same experience to all users, AUIs create a personalized experience for different users. As such, they’ve become very popular within the medical industry: While the medical provider sees one interface with additional controls and access, the patient’s view is more limited. The ability for AUIs to adapt to various users contributes to a more positive user experience while also reducing the risk for error and/or reduce the number of steps required to achieve the user’s end goal. According to some, AUIs may additionally increase system stability.
An additional benefit of AUIs is security. AUIs help minimize the risk of a data breach by limiting a user’s view of information to only relevant or essential details. Once again, this makes AUIs a good choice in industries that store and/or transmit sensitive information, such as medical data. For example, a medical practice’s computers can be set up with an AUI that keeps unauthorized individuals from accessing protected patient data. This helps the practice with compliance with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA).
The downsides to AUIs
AUIs tend to be time-consuming and difficult to design as compared to other, non-adaptive user interfaces. As compared to a non-adaptive user interface, the design process for an AUI must account for multiple design elements and layouts vs. the default. AUI design requires a high level of understanding of users’ unique needs, making them more specialized and difficult to create. What’s more, they require multiple levels and styles of implementations, adding to the complexity for designers. As a result of their complexity, AUIs tend to be more expensive to implement. In applications where time or budget are tight, a company may choose a different option.
Some other factors to consider:
- AUIs may require additional training time for users to help them understand and fully utilize the customization options.
- If integrating an AUI with an existing system or hardware, one may face compatibility issues. Additional attention may be required to ensure seamless integration with legacy systems.
- Finally, the endless customization options for AUIs can cause information overload for users. Too many choices or features can distract users from essential tasks and critical information.
The decision between adaptive and non-adaptive user interfaces requires careful consideration of the specific needs and priorities of your organization. Although AUIs offer personalized and efficient user experiences, the potential complexities and associated challenges must be evaluated to determine the most suitable approach for each specific application.
About NMG
NMG has more than 85 years of experience partnering with organizations to bring their industrial, IoT, lighting, medical, telecommunications, consumer, and aerospace products to life. We solve your most complex challenges in engineering design, manufacturing, and supply chain management.
Follow NMG
Could your company use results like this?
We want to learn about your organization and understand your unique challenges.
Get in touch!
We can’t wait to create winning solutions with you.
For general inquiries, please fill out this form and our team will be in touch shortly.